Expert Review

Our Expert Team

Every profile on KnowTheSpore is written and reviewed by mycologists, experienced foragers, and food scientists.

Every identification and safety page on KnowTheSpore is checked by a qualified reviewer before it publishes. On a site where a wrong call can be fatal, that review is the most important step we run.

Here is who does that work, what a review checks, and the standard we hold reviewers to.

A reviewer checking a wild mushroom against an illustrated field guide
Every safety page is checked against reference material and a reviewing mycologist before it publishes.

Why expert review is not optional here

Most food writing can be wrong at the edges without hurting anyone. Mushroom identification has no such margin. The gap between a choice edible and a deadly Amanita can be a single feature at the base of the stem.

So the writer never signs off on their own safety claims. A reviewing mycologist checks the work independently, and only then does a page go live.

What a review actually checks

A review is a checklist, not a glance. The reviewer confirms the accepted name and family, then works through the field marks, the edibility call, and every dangerous lookalike.

  • Identity fixed against MycoBank and Index Fungorum
  • Cap, gills or pores, stem, spore print, habitat, and odour cross-checked
  • Each toxic lookalike documented before an edibility rating stands
  • The review dated and the reviewer named on the page

The standard we hold reviewers to

A reviewer needs formal training in mycology or a long, documented record of field identification. We match reviewers to what they know best, whether that is toxic Amanita species or cultivated gourmet mushrooms.

Review is ongoing, not a one-time badge. When taxonomy changes or a better source appears, the affected pages go back through review.

Frequently Asked Questions

Who reviews the pages on this site?
Every identification and safety page is signed off by a qualified reviewing mycologist before it publishes. The reviewer is named on the page along with the date of the review.
What does a reviewing mycologist check?
They confirm the scientific name and family, cross-check the field marks, document every dangerous lookalike, and confirm the edibility rating. Only then does the page go live.
Does a review mean a mushroom is safe for me to eat?
No. A review makes our page accurate. It cannot verify the mushroom in your hand. Real identification is hands-on, and when in doubt you should throw it out.
How often are pages reviewed?
Safety pages are reviewed before they publish and again whenever the science, the sources, or the identification changes.
Can I send an expert a photo to identify my mushroom?
No. We cannot safely identify a mushroom from a photo, and we do not offer that service. For a suspected poisoning, call Poison Control or emergency services right away.